The tabletop simulator has found itself at the center of a review-bomb campaign on Steam following complaints from a user who was temporarily banned after being kicked out of the game’s global chat channel for reporting that we Are gay and trans.
The trouble started earlier this month when a table top simulator user named Xoe said he was repeatedly fired from the game’s global chat channel for sharing the fact that he was gay. Efforts to clarify the details of Chat’s moderation policies eventually led to a temporary ban on the channel. An email to table top simulator developer Berserk Games went unanswered.
Xoe then went to the table top simulator Discard, where she was told that the global chat channel is primarily for players who want to join the games, and that “sexuality is not a place to talk at festivals.” [or] Politics. “But later in the conversation, attempts to push the boundaries, to stay upright or to end the prisons, sexism and politics, but not strangely – did not give such an answer.
One moderator, Tim, tried to explain to Kicks during the discussion that the Berserk Games were only trying to avoid worse results. “The fact is that almost every instance of this kind of language in the global chat is being used in a way other than what Xoe has been advocating. Has been added to the list, “he wrote. . “As much as I enjoy discussing the virtues of internet moderation, there are only keywords that will lead to restrictions, honestly most of them are temporary and automatic.”
The problem with this approach, Xoe said in a lengthy Google document describing his experiences, is that “it is impossible to find a queer community in chat, or to ask for weird chat games.”
“You can’t play games with gay / trans representations or gay / trans experiences because you will be kicked out,” he wrote. “It’s considered against their rules.”
“Identity pressures tell people that it’s not safe to live in these places on their own. I’ve seen occasionally some people who celebrate their innocence, people say they like to be gay.” And the like, and I assume they all have to have it. I was kicked out like that when I joined. It sets an example that you are not welcome here, that you You can stay here as long as you leave your backward identity at the door. “
Shortly after posting Xoe’s mail, Berserk Games released a statement stating that the whole thing was a misunderstanding: Xoe was removed from the channel “not for revealing his identity, but for” “It simply came to our notice then.
A day later, this Disable global chat. To fully rethink its moderation policies.
The studio said, “The goal of the moderate team was to maintain global communication on the subject of board games and to reduce toxicity and hatred.” “The table top simulator acknowledges that the current moderation process of our global chat has failed to maintain its original intent and we apologize for that as well as anyone who has been hurt in the last few days or Feeling we have ‘Run out of gas’ emotionally.
Curry, one of the moderators involved, also apologized for the “poorly thought out answers”. [that] Injury, emotional trauma, and damage to reputation. “
Xoe’s complaint is fair: “When other people are allowed to talk about their heterosexual experiences but gays and trans people are silenced, you use your platform to say this.” “Only hetero and cis people are accepted here,” he wrote. The fearless answer, as far as it goes, also seems reasonable. Xoe also acknowledged that she did not think Berserk was “deliberately and deliberately trying to harm the LGBT community or have an anti-LGBT agenda.” But as his experience became more widely known, it quickly (inevitably, indeed) turned into a cultural war on steam.
Negative user reviews of the tabletop simulator began to rise on January 8, and two days later it increased, mainly due to complaints that the developers are transphobic and homophobic, and statements in support of transcripts. But there has been a similar increase in positive reviews, most of which unfortunately express real transphobic and homophobic emotions.
The number of reviews in these competitive bombing campaigns is relatively low compared to the total: 674 negative reviews and 568 positive reviews since January 8, a small portion of nearly 30,000 “tremendously positive” user reviews have been given to Table Top Simulator since its launch. Has gone 2015 Still, the sudden arrival was enough to trim Steam’s automated anti-review bomb system: all user reviews, positive and negative, posted after January 7, marked as “off topic”. That is, they will continue to appear. But it will not affect the calculation of the review score.
But while raw numbers may not increase much, it is clear that toxicity is a real problem within the table-top simulator community, and Berserk needs to take steps to address it. The studio’s initial reaction seems sincere and encouraging, but Xoe indicated that she is not coming back no matter what.
“Thanks for saying trans rights are human rights, but when you first told me it would be inappropriate to share with others, it becomes hollow.” “I’ll share my pride somewhere else. Screentop.gg looks really promising.”
I reached out to Berserk Games for comments and will update if I receive a response.